Arc's Archetype
Shiur provided courtesy of Naaleh.com
Adapted by Channie Koplowitz Stein
Although Parshat Toldos begins with the infertility of Rivkah and Yitzchak, it quickly moves into Rivka’s difficult pregnancy and the birth of the twins who would be named Eisav and Yaakov. The birth is unusual, as is the appearance of the babies. Eisav emerges first, fully covered in hair as an adult, while Yaakov is born holding onto the heel of Eisav. Therefore, his name is Yaakov, derived from Eikev/heel.
Both the appearance of the twins and their names portend their future character. The Torah itself alludes to the hairiness of Eisav as indicating full development, and the name Eisav is derived from עשוי / Asuy/ Fully developed. Rabbi Roberts explains that this was the attitude of Eisav. He felt he was “fully developed” with no need for improvement or growth. But we should be modeling ourselves after the cherubim covering the Ark, childlike, with outstretched wings turned toward heaven, hoping to grow and receive. Even Yehoshua, Moshe Rabbenu’s successor, is called a naar, a youth, even as he was already middle aged, because he was constantly learning from Moshe Rabbenu.
In contrast, Yaakov always felt he was at the bottom, like the heel of the body, striving to grow and reaching upward. As Rabbi Fryman adds, from head to foot, Yaakov was a unified whole, serving Hashem in every part of his body. Here he is the heel, but later he will receive the name Yisroel/ישראל, an anagram of לי ראש/ I have a head [with which to serve Hashem], as well as the heel/toe of my birth.
Although Eisav was fully formed physically, writes Rabbi Shmulevitz zt”l citing the Kli Yakar zy”a, like all human beings, his spiritual and emotional aspects needed to develop, and that requires work. Yaakov understood this. Yaakov understood that in these aspects you are born on the lowest aspect, the lowest rung.
Rabbi Kofman zt”lmakes a fairly well known observation of society. Often those children who grow up having everything feel that they have no need to work on themselves. Because they have everything, they believe they already are everything they need to be. This is not Jewish thinking. We are born to work, to strive. Rabbi Kofman cites an incident from Rabbi Segal zt”l of Manchester who was once in shul in Austria that lacked one man for a minyan. A congregant jokingly quipped, “Let’s create a golem/humanoid.” Rabbi Segal responded brilliantly, “To make a golem takes no intelligence; to create a human being from a golem, that takes intelligence.”
The first time we see the word eikev/heel in the Torah is after the snake had enticed Chava to eat of the forbidden fruit. Hashem declares that henceforth, the snake will always attempt to bite man’s heel, but the descendants of Chava must crush his head. What this means, writes Rabbi Weller in The Book and the Blade,” is that the snake will always try to impede man’s progress, to keep him from stepping forward. But we must add the “yud” to the heel, adding the letter indicating the future, of moving forward, to the beginning, the “head” of eikev. He wants to bite the heel, and we are bidden to crush its head.
The Maharal zy”a, in his mystical way, suggests the Yaakov and Eisav were actually one entity split in two. Eisav encompasses all the physicality, and Yaakov, while maintaining only the flimsiest foothold on physicality, was completely spiritual.
The Shvilei Pinchas expands on the Maharal by explaining the Megaleh Amukos zy”a. The names of the twins appear to be counterintuitive. Esau/עשו should be עשוי/Esui/Done and Yaakov/יעקב should have been Eikev/עקב/Heel, not will heel. However, at birth, Yaakov grabbed the “yud” at the end of Eisav’s name and added it to the head of his name, transforming it to Yaakov. It is this “yud” that is the focal point of the continuous battle between Yaakov and Esau.
When Hashem created Adam, He created him with two yud’s, וייצר. One yud represents the yetzer hatov and the other yud represents the yetzer horo. The yud of the four lettered Name of Hashem represents the trait of chochmah/wisdom. Yaakov wanted to control wisdom for sanctity, while Eisav wanted it for physicality. Eisav proved this when he sold the birthright and then spurned the birthright whose major function was spiritual, to become the priests of Hashem. Yaakov wrests the yud of Eisav’s name to use that wisdom for sanctity. Yaakov uses that chochmah to see the remote consequences of his actions, that which is farthest away, as the heel is the farthest part of the body.
Interestingly, this battle between the two does not end with the death of Yaakov, notes Rabbi Mintzberg zt”lin Ben Melech. When Bnei Yisroel bring Yaakov’s remains back from Egypt to be buried in Meorat Hamachpelah, even then, Eisav tries to block the burial. Evil rears its head at the beginning, but good, although emerging in a weaker state, holds on and prevails in the end. The name Yaakov signifies this constant battle, while in the end, he is given the name Yisroel, he who fought and prevailed.
But prevailing and winning is not automatic. It requires constant effort and struggle. And that is exactly how one grows, through the struggle, through grabbing on to the heel that would push you down, not letting go, pulling yourself up, write the Omek Haparshah. [I wonder where the phrase “pulling yourself up by the bootstraps” came from. CKS]
While Eikev would have memorialized the past as his name, Yaakov symbolizes the future, for the descendants of Eisav will constantly try to crush the descendants of Yaakov. However, when Moshiach comes, Yaakov will emerge holding Esau’s heel [so that Esau cannot progress]. It is Hashem, alluding to the future, Who names this baby Yaakov. While it appears that “the wicked bloom like grass,” in the end, it will be “the righteous man who will blossom like a palm tree, [Tehillim 92]” writes Rabbi Williger. It is the eternal struggle between good and evil, whether represented by descendants of Esau or by those who embrace similar evil ways, Lavan, Pharaoh, until the Saviors will arise in Mount Zion and rend judgments on Esau and his spiritual descendants.
In the meantime, the struggle continues. How do we prevail? Grab him by the tail, by his weak spots, and strengthen yourself where he is weak, with what he tramples on. Strengthen yourself in the small mitzvoth that are our foundation. Esau spurns it all. Because he spurned the בכרה, the birthright and its spiritual obligations, he lost the ברכה, the blessing of the firstborn. Pay attention to the small mitzvoth. Take what appears to be the heel, and move it to the head. Make those important.
In Mesillos Bilvovom, Rabbi Eisenberger takes a common phrase and turns it on its head. How often do we hear [or say ourselves] that we are not ready to undertake a particular mitzvah or attitude? We say, “I’m not holding there yet.” This mindset is a trap that keeps you from growing. We are living in the era of the ikvisa d’Meshicha, the [coming] footsteps/heels of Moshiach. Let us not trample on these mitzvoth. This is the yetzer horo talking, preventing us from growing. We may not be there yet, although we may not be fully ready yet, we need to take that first step, and continue step by step. Don’t worry that it’s not perfect, that you do not yet understand it or know every detail. Align your will to His will and just do it.
The understanding and sense of sanctity of our generation is much weaker than in past generations. The outside world has infected us with the excitement produced by outside stimuli, with the idea that for us to do anything, we need to “feel it,” to have the endorphins flowing, to be in the mood. If you are acting only when you are in the mood, you are doing it for yourself, not to serve Hashem. You have not accepted the “yoke of Heaven,” the aligning your will to His.
The heel has very little feeling, but we still need to hold onto it. We still need to have the wisdom of the yud, to know to serve Hashem even when we don’t feel it. Yaakov is holding Eisav’s heel.
The Tallelei Chaim approaches our image from the perspective of the hand rather than of the heel. He suggests that the heel represents the innate characteristics and physical propensities of a person, but the hand represents a person’s free will to submit to those urges or to harness them, to grab onto them and use them to accomplish Hashem’s will. And Yaakov can grab onto the very negative characteristics of Eisav, learn how to use those traits, and gain strength from them without succumbing to them.
In a profound and deeply psychological analysis, Rabbi Bernstein quoting R’ Heymen interprets the positions of the twins’ birth through the eyes of their father Yitzchak. Arguably, the most seminal experience of Yitzchak’s life was akeidas Yitzchak, literally, the binding of Yitzchak on the altar. To prevent movement, the offering on the altar was hogtied, its hand and feet all bound together. When Yitzchak saw Yaakov emerging, holding onto Eisav’s heel, Yitzchak remembered how his hands and feet were bound together in perfect submission to Hashem’s will. Yitzchak saw this as a sign that both children would continue this legacy. Although Yitzchak could not have known that Eisav would choose not to use his talents and characteristics in Hashem’s service, he named Yaakov for the heel, believing that to be the future of his sons. Only Rivkah, certainly having received the prophecy about the twins’ future, knew the truth about Eisav.
As a final thought, we know the prophecy Rivkah received during her pregnancy; the nations descended from the two brothers would be in constant battle, with one dominating while the other would be dominated. Eisav’s domination of Yitzchak would never be total, for Yitzchak would always be grabbing at Esau’s heels, writes Rabbi Parness in Lev Tahor. In the end, the sovereignty and empire of Eisav will fall, and the descendants of Yaakov will prevail.
While the heel may indeed be the lowest point of the body, no man could stand upright without it. Let us keep our heels strong, let us maintain focus not only on all the major parts of the Torah, but also on the small details, for without them, we cannot remain strong and upright. That is how we defeat the evil both within ourselves and without.
